Nellie Gail Ranch, California coastal real estate

Equestrian Community

Nellie Gail Ranch

10

Homes for Sale

$4,685,000

Single-Family Median List Price

–

Condo & Townhome Median List Price

$934

Price per Sq Ft

31

Avg. Days on Market

$3,498,500

Avg. Sold Price (90 Days)

Active listings in Nellie Gail Ranch as of , per CRMLS. Sold price averages the 6 homes that closed in the last 90 days. A dash means too few listings or sales to publish a meaningful figure. Updated daily.

Current Listings

Homes for Sale in Nellie Gail Ranch

The 10 highest-priced homes on the market now, updated from CRMLS throughout the day.

See All Homes in Nellie Gail Ranch →

1–6 of 10

Listings provided by CRMLS. “Listed by” identifies the listing agent and brokerage; Kyle Shutts and Arbor Real Estate are the advertising broker unless otherwise noted. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. Inquiries are answered by Kyle Shutts, Arbor Real Estate.

At a Glance

Nellie Gail Ranch Facts

Location
Orange County, California
Size
More than 1,350 acres
Riding trails
About 25 miles, kept by the owners association
Equestrian center
Three lighted arenas and 96 stalls
School district
Saddleback Valley Unified
Typical sold price
$2.6 million to $4.83 million
Typical home size
4,772 sq ft
Typical lot size
22,263 sq ft
Homes built
1970s to 1990s
HOA dues
Most homes, median $192/month
Homes with a private pool
About 83%
Homes with a view
About 71%
Homes sold, last 12 months
42

Home figures from CRMLS sales and listings as of .

Market Conditions

Is Nellie Gail Ranch a Buyer’s or Seller’s Market?

Seller’s Market

2.9 months of supply

10 homes are for sale, and about 3.5 sell each month, so today’s inventory would sell out in about 2.9 months at the current pace. Under 4 months generally favors sellers; over 6 favors buyers.

4

New Listings, Last 30 Days

7

In Escrow Now

30%

Listings With a Price Cut

Median cut 6.5%

29

Median Days on Market, Listed Now

$2.9M to $8M

Asking Prices Now

Homes for sale and in escrow from CRMLS as of ; sales as of . Months of supply divides homes for sale by the average monthly sales of the last 12 months.

Market Trends

Nellie Gail Ranch Market Report

Homes sold in Nellie Gail Ranch over the last 12 months, from CRMLS closed sales as of . Updated weekly.

42

Homes Sold, 12 Months

▲ 27.3% vs prior year

$3,687,500

Median Sold Price

▲ 11.4% vs prior year

$793

Median Price per Sq Ft

▼ 3.2% vs prior year

47

Avg. Days on Market

▲ 1 days vs prior year

98.1%

Sale-to-List Price

▲ 0.6 pts vs prior year

17%

Sold Over Asking

$166.7M

Total Sales Volume

$8.55M

Highest Sale, 12 Months

Highest sale of the last 12 months: 27501 Boothill Court, $8,550,000, closed Jul 2026. Listed by Melody Smith, Anvil Real Estate.

Median sold price by month
$2.5M$3M$3.5M$4M$4.5MDec '25Feb '26Apr '26Jun '26Aug '26Oct '26$3.02M
Median price per sq ft by month
$600$700$800$900Dec '25Feb '26Apr '26Jun '26Aug '26Oct '26$770
Homes sold by month
0510Dec '25Feb '26Apr '26Jun '26Aug '26Oct '26
Sale-to-list price by month
94.0%96.0%98.0%100.0%102.0%Dec '25Feb '26Apr '26Jun '26Aug '26Oct '2695.7%
View as a table
Nellie Gail Ranch sales by month
MonthSalesMedian sold priceMedian price per sq ftSale-to-list
Nov 20252–––
Dec 20253$2,800,000$89597.2%
Jan 20265$3,900,000$87896.7%
Feb 20260–––
Mar 20263$3,200,000$91498.5%
Apr 20266$4,227,000$75798.8%
May 20264$3,772,500$70299.4%
Jun 20264$4,380,000$763100.0%
Jul 202610$3,425,000$80997.5%
Aug 20263$3,015,000$77095.7%
Sep 20262–––
Oct 20261–––

A gap or dash means fewer than 3 sales in that month.

Inside the Numbers

How Homes Sold in Nellie Gail Ranch

The last 12 months of closed sales, broken down by price, bedrooms and home type.

Sales by Price

  • $2M to $3M10 (24%)
  • $3M to $4M17 (40%)
  • $4M to $5M11 (26%)
  • $5M to $7.5M1 (2%)
  • $7.5M to $10M3 (7%)

Sold Price vs. Asking

  • Over asking17%
  • At asking17%
  • Under asking67%
Median sale-to-list price
98.1%
Median vs. original asking price
97.6%

“At asking” means within half a percent of the final list price.

By Bedrooms
BedroomsSalesMedian priceMedian sizePrice / sq ft
3 bedrooms2–––
4 bedrooms13$2,840,0002,865 sq ft$906
5 bedrooms16$3,662,5004,688 sq ft$768
6+ bedrooms11$4,800,0007,110 sq ft$724
By Home Type
TypeSalesMedian pricePrice / sq ftMedian daysSale-to-list
Single-family home42$3,687,500$7932398.1%

From CRMLS closed sales as of . A dash means fewer than 3 sales in that group.

By Price

What Your Money Buys in Nellie Gail Ranch

Recent sales split into thirds by price, over the last 12 months.

  1. $2.22 million to $3.1 million

    Typically 4 bedrooms, about 2,865 sq ft, on lots around 21,113 sq ft, most often a single-family home. Based on 14 sales.

  2. $3.15 million to $4.12 million

    Typically 5 bedrooms, about 4,489 sq ft, on lots around 27,125 sq ft, most often a single-family home. Based on 14 sales.

  3. $4.3 million to $8.55 million

    Typically 6 bedrooms, about 6,976 sq ft, on lots around 23,627 sq ft, most often a single-family home. Based on 14 sales.

Recently Sold

Recent Sales in Nellie Gail Ranch

AddressSold priceListing creditBeds / BathsSq ftSold
25901 Prairestone Drive$3,625,000Listed by Reza Shirangi, The Oppenheim Group5 / 64,049Nov 6, 2026
24891 Buckskin Drive$3,700,000Listed by Bradley Feldman, Berkshire Hathaway HomeService5 / 44,533Oct 8, 2026
25111 Buckboard Lane$2,975,000Listed by Madelaine Whiteman, Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices California Properties4 / 22,064Sep 10, 2026
25472 Rapid Falls$3,826,000Listed by Tony Bartos, Pacific Sotheby's Int'l Realty4 / 45,080Sep 8, 2026
25402 Gallup Circle$3,850,000Listed by Bradley Feldman, Berkshire Hathaway HomeService4 / 55,000Aug 27, 2026
25171 Stageline Drive$3,015,000Listed by Abby Modarres, Compass5 / 54,028Aug 26, 2026
26576 Stetson$2,220,000Listed by Andy Galfi, Landmark Realtors4 / 32,450Aug 7, 2026
26346 Sorrell$2,565,000Listed by Nancy Fitzgerald, Coldwell Banker Realty4 / 44,031Jul 30, 2026

Sold listings provided by CRMLS. “Listed by” identifies the listing agent and listing brokerage. Kyle Shutts and Arbor Real Estate are the advertising broker unless otherwise noted. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

About Nellie Gail Ranch

Nellie Gail Ranch is an equestrian community of more than 1,350 acres in Laguna Hills, named for Nellie Gail Moulton, whose husband, Lewis Moulton, and his partner Jean Pierre Daguerre once ranched more than 21,000 acres of this part of Orange County. Its owners association keeps about 25 miles of riding trails and five parks, and the community has its own equestrian center, tennis center, swim center and clubhouse.

Housing Stock

Homes are single-family houses on large lots, from original homes to new custom builds, and some lots are set up for horses. All exterior changes need the approval of the association's Architectural Review Committee.

Lifestyle & Amenities

The Nellie Gail Ranch Equestrian Center has three large lighted sand arenas and 96 stalls, with trainers and lesson horses for riders without a horse of their own. The tennis center has 10 lighted hard courts and eight pickleball courts and also offers public memberships. Laguna Beach and the coast are a short drive away.

Neighborhoods & Enclaves

Trail-Side Lots

Homes whose lots meet the association's riding trails.

Hillside View Lots

Homes on the hills of the ranch, with views over the canyons.

Original and Rebuilt Homes

Original houses alongside new custom builds on the same large lots.

What Sets the Market Apart

  • Horse keeping depends on the lot: confirm with the city and the association what a property allows before you buy.
  • The lot, its usable area and its trail access shape value as much as the house.
  • All exterior changes need the approval of the association's Architectural Review Committee.

Where It Is

Map of Nellie Gail Ranch

For sale Sold in the last 12 months

Streets in Nellie Gail Ranch

Streets with a home sold or listed here in the last two years.

  • Anvil Circle
  • Black Horse Lane
  • Boothill Court
  • Broken Bit
  • Buckboard
  • Buckboard Lane
  • Buckskin Drive
  • Dapple Grey Drive
  • Deputy Circle
  • Derbyhill
  • Derbyhill Drive
  • Dillon Road
  • Fargo
  • Flintlock
  • Flintlock Ln
  • Gallup Circle
  • Glen Canyon Drive
  • Greenfield Drive
  • Hidden Trail Road
  • Highplains
  • Highplains Terrace
  • Horseshoe Cr
  • Lone Pine Circle
  • Lost Trail Drive
  • Mustang Drive
  • NE Gallup Circle
  • Nellie Gail
  • Nellie Gail Road
  • Oroville Place
  • Pecos Road
  • Pinestrap Cir
  • Pinto Court
  • Poker Flats
  • Poker Flats Place
  • Prairestone Drive
  • Rangewood Road
  • Rapid Falls
  • Red Corral Road
  • Red Lodge
  • Rocking Horse
  • Rockridge Road
  • Rodeo Circle
  • Saddle Rock Place
  • Shenandoah Drive
  • Sheriff Road
  • Silver Saddle Lane
  • Sorrell
  • Sorrell Place
  • Spotted Pony Lane
  • Stageline
  • Stageline Drive
  • Stagewood Court
  • Stetson
  • Waterwheel
  • Wild View Terrace

From Kyle

Kyle's Take on Nellie Gail Ranch

Nellie Gail Ranch is one of the few places in South County where the land still sets the terms. The lot, its slope and how it meets the trails matter as much as the house, and two homes of similar size can be very different purchases. I look first at how a property uses its land: how much of it is usable, where the trail connects, and whether the setting can support horses, a pool or guest quarters without compromise. Before planning any change, I would confirm what the lot allows with the city and the association's Architectural Review Committee.

For sellers, I present the property as a whole: the approach, the grounds, the views and the way the house opens to its land. Many buyers here are choosing a way of life as much as a floor plan, so trail access, outdoor spaces and any equestrian facilities deserve as much attention in the marketing as the interiors.

Kyle Shutts, Arbor Real Estate, DRE# 02060736

Questions

Nellie Gail Ranch FAQ

What is the median home price in Nellie Gail Ranch?

Over the last 12 months, the median sold price for homes in Nellie Gail Ranch was $3,687,500, across 42 sales, or about $793 per square foot. Single-family homes listed for sale now have a median asking price of $4,685,000. Figures are from CRMLS as of 2026-11-19.

How long do homes take to sell in Nellie Gail Ranch?

Homes that sold in Nellie Gail Ranch over the last 12 months spent an average of 47 days on the market. The median home sold for 98.1% of its final list price.

Is Nellie Gail Ranch a buyer's or seller's market right now?

Nellie Gail Ranch is a seller's market, with about 2.9 months of supply: 10 homes for sale against roughly 4 sales a month over the last year. Under 4 months of supply generally favors sellers and over 6 favors buyers. About 30% of current listings have had a price reduction. Figures are from CRMLS as of 2026-11-19.

Do homes in Nellie Gail Ranch sell over asking price?

Over the last 12 months, 17% of homes in Nellie Gail Ranch sold above their final asking price, 17% sold at asking and 67% sold below. The median home sold for 98.1% of its list price.

How many homes are for sale in Nellie Gail Ranch?

There are 10 homes for sale in Nellie Gail Ranch as of 2026-11-19, including 4 listed in the last 30 days, and 7 more are in escrow. Asking prices range from $2,899,000 to $7,999,000.

Do homes in Nellie Gail Ranch have HOA dues?

About 100% of homes sold or listed in Nellie Gail Ranch recently report HOA dues, with a median of $192 per month. Confirm the current amount and what it covers before you buy.

What streets are in Nellie Gail Ranch?

Streets with recent sales or listings in Nellie Gail Ranch include Anvil Circle, Black Horse Lane, Boothill Court, Broken Bit, Buckboard, Buckboard Lane, Buckskin Drive, Dapple Grey Drive, Deputy Circle, and Derbyhill, among others.

Who was Nellie Gail?

Nellie Gail Moulton (1878 to 1972), a painter and the wife of rancher Lewis Moulton, whose ranch with partner Jean Pierre Daguerre once covered more than 21,000 acres of this part of Orange County. She managed the ranch for 12 years after her husband died in 1938, and the community grew on land sold after her death.

How many miles of riding trails are in Nellie Gail Ranch?

About 25 miles, kept by the Nellie Gail Ranch Owners Association, along with five association parks.

Does Nellie Gail Ranch have an equestrian center?

Yes. The equestrian center has three large lighted sand arenas and 96 stalls, with trainers and lesson horses for riders without a horse of their own.

Can non-residents join the Nellie Gail Ranch tennis center?

Yes. The tennis center, with 10 lighted hard courts and eight pickleball courts, offers public memberships.

What school district serves Nellie Gail Ranch?

Saddleback Valley Unified. Confirm the assignment for a specific address with the district.

Kyle Shutts, Real Estate Professional

Meet Kyle

Kyle Shutts

Real Estate Professional

My path into real estate started early. Growing up, I helped my father with the marketing and photography for his real estate business, and saw firsthand how presentation, strategy and execution drive results. Before moving fully into real estate, I built my foundation on a high-producing mortgage lending team, which taught me the financial side of every deal.

Today I bring a strategic, detail-driven approach to every client, with clear communication, hands-on service and proactive guidance at every step. My goal is simple: protect your interests, maximize your outcome, and make the experience as smooth and stress-free as possible.

5.0

Google Rating

10+

Years Experience

1,000+

Career Transactions

$1B+

Career Volume

Career totals, combining real estate sales and mortgage loans. NMLS #2034158.

More About Kyle →

Client Reviews

Read All Reviews →
The rear of the main house and the pool on a sunny day, with a stone terrace and outdoor seating

Your Nellie Gail Ranch Real Estate Expert

$13,850,000

A 2.2-acre compound with six bedrooms and nine bathrooms across about 10,500 square feet in six buildings.

A record-setting sale. Kyle Shutts represented the buyer.

Keep Exploring

Nearby Areas

Start Here

Ready to Make a Move?

A confidential conversation about your timeline, your target areas, and current inventory, with no obligation.